Refutation of al-Qaradawi
1st: Allah has purchased Muslims to deal justly with non-Muslims and also to getting kind in their mind in line with the verse during the Quran:
a€?Allah cannot prohibit you to definitely deal rightly and lavishly with those that fought not just against you on membership of institution and would not travel your from your very own homes. Verily, Allah likes folks that handle fairness.a€? ( al-Mumtahina : 8)
By pointing out this verse, al-Qaradawi claims it is allowed to congratulate non-Muslims within their holiday season since this comprises becoming kind and just for them. However, to draw this conclusion out of this verse try a blunder because becoming kind and simply to other individuals will never be permissible whether it includes disobedience to Allah. Due to the fact Prophet i·? mentioned: a€?There isn’t any behavior to your individual in the event it calls for sin; obedience should be only in that particular which happens to be best and proper.a€? 2 however, discover clear disobedience to Allah when non-Muslims dedicate functions of shirk and sin in addition to the Muslim congratulates them on days past whereby those act include devoted.
2nd: The Prophet i·? purchased Asmaa€™ bint Abi Bakr, as soon as the polytheist mama arrived and visited this model, by stating: a€?Keep good connections with the mummy.a€? 3 Again, this is a hadith that is `amm (general) and mutlaq (complete), hence, it states practically nothing about holiday breaks. On top of that, it is actually a loan application of a€?behave along with them nowadays please.a€? In order to apply this verse to indicate that it is allowable to congratulate and/or partake in non-Muslim trips was contradictory along with other Islamic messages, including any time Allah ordered people never to hear our personal parents should they put all of us to make acts of shirk or additional sins:
a€?but once the two aim together with you to help you join in worship with me at night many compared to which you have no information, after that follow them not just, but react together with them in the arena please.a€? (Luqman: 15).
In outlining the true reason for the versea€™s disclosure, the students of tafsir claimed that it was shared in the matter of Saa€?ad ibn Abi Waqas, whoever woman ordered him to observe the woman and disbelieve in Islam. Upon this, Allah expose the above mentioned verse getting those believers for obedient their mothers except in case that that concerned disbelief or shirk. 4
One-third: Yes, Allah enjoys permitted Muslims to have from chicken of those belonging to the guide and get married using womenfolk. The issue is: If a Muslim marries such someone, next how could it be easy for him to live in equilibrium, tranquility, and enjoy together with her although it is not congratulating them or the lady parents on the breaks? This particular qiyas (analogical sense) happens to be blemished because one of the main pillars of qiyas is missing, and that is the a€?illah (operative cause). 5 The a€?illah in this situation will be the Jews plus the Christians have a Divine Scripture, which entails that Muslims sugarbook mobile site can take in utilizing chicken and marry from them. However, it is certainly not allowable proper in making qiyas within this since judgment is definitely khass (certain) or muqayyad (confined) to only both functions. Among the many rules in making an allegorical understanding (taa€™wil) usually khass and muqayyad usually are not available for additional conceptions. 6 In Addition, qiyas will never become as loaded with authority because definitive proofs or ijmaa€?. What this means is about the result of qiyas must in conformity on your intentions associated with the Sharia€?a to find out its concord because of the Islamic messages. 7 as well as in the scenario of congratulating and partaking within the trips of the non-Muslims, an ijmaa€? was revealed on the law by students instance Ibn al-Qayyim, hence, making this qiyas incorrect.
4th: al-Qaradawi likewise mentions the verse in which Allah countries, a€?when you’re welcomed with a salutation, greet inturn with what is better than they, or (around) send it back equally.a€? (al-Nisaa€™: 86). Again, the utilization of verses from Quran for applications besides the things they had been meant for within context is a flawed strategy. This verse is actually certain inside salutation that’s common among Muslims, which can be to state salam a€?alaykum or something much like it. If discussing this verse, these scholars of tafsir state they regarding saying salam a€?alaykum, and not one of them managed to get general that include all sorts of hello. 8
Abdullah trash Bayyah/Hamza Yusuf
Trash Bayyah 14 within his reserve, Sinaa€?at al-Fatwa wa Fiqh al-Aqalliyyat, quotes the same proofs and standards as al-Qaraa??awi, but the man includes in this article discourse:
The students need disagreed upon this matter of congratulating the non-Muslims (on their fests). Through the madhhab of Imam Ahmad discover three suggestions: a) its restricted, b) it really is disliked and c) it is allowable. It is this previous thoughts (of permissibility) that Sheikh Taqi al-Din Ibn Taymiyyah opted for due to its maslaa??ah (overall close) and this refers to the opinion that individuals choose aswell. As a result, its allowable to congratulate them (non-Muslims), to console these people on their own grief, in order to browse their particular ill. Al-Mardawi features cited most of these narrations within his book, al-Ina??af. And defining discussed within regarding the some other literature in regards to Ibn Taymiyyah is almost certainly not in accord with his established feedback. 15